It’s hard to say if this one is a winner or a wadder. The reality is that it’s too big and I choose the wrong fabric to line the suspenders, a slippery poly lining. It should be a wadder. It totally failed the work test because the suspenders fell off my shoulders all day long. However, I love how it looks! I moved the zipper to the back and the waistband has side seams, so if I wasn’t lazy, I could probably take it in. Whatever, I plan to wear the heck out of it.